Appenzell
Switzerland
A Daily Compendium
of Free-Market Thinking
The Daily Bell Newswire - It's FREE!    


Guest Editorial

Protecting Your IRA - Part 2: Getting Your IRA Out of Town

Thursday, July 29, 2010 – by  Terry Coxon


Terry Coxon

In Part I, "The Danger," I explained the wide investment freedom you can achieve with an IRA structure that not one investor in a thousand knows is possible. It's the Open Opportunity structure, which is an IRA that holds a single asset – a limited liability company (LLC) that you manage. Because you are the LLC's Manager, with your own hands on the LLC's checkbook and with full authority to act when you see a profitable opportunity, your IRA can invest in just about anything.

That investment freedom has obvious implications for profitability. You're not limited to stocks and bonds. You can go wherever you think you'll get the best return. You can run your IRA more like an business and not just an account for passive investments.

And investment freedom has not-so-obvious implications for safety. Open Opportunity IRAs make up less than 1% of the IRA universe. So if and when a team of Congressional staffers or a group of Treasury Department bureaucrats get busy drafting up new rules aimed at skimming a few hundred billion dollars from IRAs, Open Opportunity IRAs probably won't be part of their thinking. The new rules, whatever they might be, could turn out to be ineffectual when applied to Open Opportunity IRAs.

A Foreign Company for Your IRA

There is a further way the Open Opportunity structure can get your IRA out of harm's way. The LLC that is inside the IRA can own a foreign company that you also manage. The foreign company then would own the investments you want. This could add more protection against any new program for the Government to dip into your IRA because the foreign company, being foreign, wouldn't be subject to U.S. laws. And shares in the foreign company would be illiquid and hard to value, whereas any new rules are likely to assume that IRA assets are fully liquid (easy to value, easy to sell) – an assumption that is correct for 99.9% of all IRA wealth but that would be way off base for a foreign company owned by an IRA.

There are two foreign company strategies that work well with an Open Opportunity IRA, and each gives you an extra benefit of its own.

Foreign holding company. The foreign company that's inside your IRA could be an LLC formed offshore that you use as a holding company to buy and own the investments you want. The extra benefit you get, vs. using an LLC formed in the U.S., is a much warmer welcome from foreign financial institutions, which can lead to still more investment choices and better profits.

Most foreign banks and brokers have become shy of dealing directly with U.S. citizens. They are terrified of getting entangled in the legal machinery of U.S. financial regulation and taxation. So when an American knocks on the door, they're inclined to say "Nobody home." Using a foreign LLC goes a long way toward eliminating that problem. A foreign bank, broker or mutual fund takes a lot of comfort in knowing that it is dealing with a non-U.S. company, even if the company is beneficially owned by an American, through his IRA.

Foreign operating company. The second way to use a foreign company inside your IRA is to operate a business through it. If the work you do now has – or could have – an international dimension, you may be able to do that work for your IRA's foreign company in a zero-tax or low-tax jurisdiction. Dividends the foreign company pays would flow to your IRA, where they would be tax-deferred or, in the case of a Roth, tax-free even when you take the money out. For example, if you are considering building an internet business, you could be build it inside your IRA's foreign company. If the company keeps all its activities outside the U.S. and resides in a zero-tax jurisdiction, the business itself will be tax free. And when the company pays the profits to your IRA, that income would stay free of current tax.

An Open Opportunity IRA is remarkably – surprisingly – versatile and full of advantages. It can even lop a big chunk off the tax cost of converting a traditional IRA to a Roth IRA. And that's the focus of Part III, "Saving Big on A Roth Conversion."

(If you missed Part I of Protecting Your IRA, you can find it here: Protecting Your IRA – Part 1: The Danger.)


Editor's Note: As it probably was for you, it was a welcome discovery to learn of a practical way to move IRA assets out of the U.S, as explained in this issue's editorial from Terry Coxon. If you'd like to learn more about putting a foreign company into your IRA (a company you would manage), we suggest that you consider getting a copy of Unleash Your IRA. This remarkable and clearly presented report on the Open Opportunity IRA structure explains all that you can accomplish with your IRA, and it covers all the rules and how to make them work for you. The report is available only online. You can find details at Unleash Your IRA. The report isn't free, but if you want to get full investment freedom and the maximum benefit from your IRA, it's a bargain.

Post Feedback

We look forward to reading your feedback. All comments are automatically posted. However, please note that any posts containing harassment, vulgarity, personal attacks or those which are deemed to be of a violent nature are not welcomed and will either not appear or be removed.






View Feedback

Posted by Kevin Beck on 7/29/2010 8:23:05 AM

I do have one question, and maybe this can be passed on to Terry Coxon for a response.

Currently, if you operate a business entity inside your IRA, you would be subject to UBTI (Unrelated Business Taxable Income). This would result in your IRA (or the LLC) having to pay tax on the LLC income. Am I uncovering an issue that should have been covered in the original article, or am I just off my rocker on this?

Posted by Boatman on 7/29/2010 8:53:31 AM

This is a gem daily bell

Posted by Fred on 7/29/2010 11:27:43 AM

Great article. I had no idea. I'll be looking into Open Opportunity IRA's immediately. Thanks,.

Posted by CPA on 7/29/2010 12:14:48 PM

@ Kevin:

UBTI is complicated and the IRA is subject to it if you are OPERATING a business. I believe the example above is when your IRA invests, loans money to, or has preferred shares in a foreign operating company. The IRA is not buying/selling the goods, but earning passive income. To my understanding, passive income streams are not subject to UBTI.

Posted by IRA LLC on 7/30/2010 8:24:11 AM

YES certain transactions are subject to UBTI,even in an IRA LLC. Sometimes you can structure the transactions so they are passive. Like loaning money vs. participating or something. I don't remember the details BUT you are absolutely correct you can have UBTI in an IRA LLC...and I believe you must make sure you have the funds (or borrow them in the IRA LLC) to pay. This is not tax advice.

Post Feedback

We look forward to reading your feedback. All comments are automatically posted. However, please note that any posts containing harassment, vulgarity, personal attacks or those which are deemed to be of a violent nature are not welcomed and will either not appear or be removed.








[Most Recent Quotes from www.kitco.com]

News & Analysis
09/04/10 US Fed Gains Power, Loses Credibility?
09/03/10 Kenya – New World Building Block
09/03/10 Psychic Regulation
09/02/10 Bank Run 2011?
09/02/10 Mises Shakes the World?
09/01/10 DC Begins the Bust Up
Guest Editorials
09/04/10 The Mind Conspirators, by Nelson Hultberg
09/03/10 Revisiting Wealth Redistribution, by Dr. Tibor Machan
09/01/10 Tempted by One Size Fits All, by Dr. Tibor Machan

Subscribe to the
Daily Bell Newswire

It's FREE!
Timely email notification of...
  • Breaking News
  • Feature Interviews
  • Guest Editorials
  • White Papers
  • eBooks & Shorts
  • Special FREE offers
...and much much more!
Exclusive Interviews
09/05/10 Nathaniel Branden on Mastering the Six Pillars of Esteem and 'Honoring' One's-Self
08/29/10 Steve Forbes on Overseas Wars, the Coming Gold Standard and the Rise of 'Citizen Agitation'
08/22/10 Nelson Hultberg on Libertarian-Conservatism and His New Conservative American Political Party
© Copyright 2008 - 2010 Appenzeller Business Press AG (ARBP). All Rights Reserved. The Daily Bell is an informative compendium of independent economic views and analysis, which is published by ARBP. The information contained in the Daily Bell is for informational purposes only, is impersonal and not tailored to the investment needs of any particular person and should not be construed as financial or investment advice. ARBP does not accept any liability or responsibility for, nor does it verify the accurateness of the information being provided in the Daily Bell. Daily Bell articles and interviews may include the contributions of several Daily Bell editors and may require factual editing after their initial post. Readers of the Daily Bell or any affiliated or linked sources or sites must accept the responsibility for performing their own due diligence before acting on any of the information provided within the report regardless of the source. In addition to proprietary, internally generated content, the Daily Bell publishes guest editorials from a selection of free-market thinkers, which may have been reprinted elsewhere and are not necessarily representative of ARBP's editorial views. Copyright is attributed to the author of any guest editorials featured at the Daily Bell, unless noted otherwise. ARBP often uses images licensed from Getty Images on the Daily Bell website.